Three neighbours support a proposal and two oppose it: has it passed? In a co-owned building, that headcount is not enough. Co-owners do not necessarily hold equal voting rights, and different decisions use different calculations. Understanding the outcome starts with identifying exactly what the meeting is being asked to decide.
Are people counted, or voting rights?
In principle, each co-owner has voting rights corresponding to their ownership share in the common parts. Someone who owns several units does not become several separate co-owners: their voting rights must be calculated from the shares attached to their units.
However, a restriction protects the balance between owners. Where one co-owner holds more than half of the ownership shares, their voting rights are reduced to the combined voting rights of the other co-owners. The share of the property owned and the voting weight that can actually be used are therefore not always identical. This rule is set out in Article 19, first paragraph, of the Law of 16 May 1975.
This reduction is not a mere counting detail: the majorities required by the law are calculated taking it into account where it applies (article 9 of the Grand-Ducal Regulation of 13 June 1975).
Why does the reference total change?
For decisions covered by Article 15, the majority is calculated using the voting rights of co-owners present or properly represented. For decisions covered by Article 16, such as appointing the property manager (syndic), the calculation uses the voting rights of all co-owners.
Consider a fictional example, after any necessary voting-right adjustments. The building has 1,000 votes, with 600 present or represented. A proposal receives 400 votes in favour and 200 against. It meets the Article 15 majority, but not the Article 16 majority, which requires more than half of all 1,000 votes. The same numerical result can therefore lead to different outcomes depending on the decision concerned.
This outcome does not close the matter: having failed to reach the Article 16 majority, a new general meeting may be convened and decide, on the same point, by the Article 15 majority (Article 16, final paragraph).
Are there other requirements?
Yes. Under Article 17, certain decisions require a majority of the members of the co-owners’ association representing at least three quarters of the voting rights. Two conditions must then be checked: the number of co-owners supporting the decision and the voting rights they represent.
Some decisions escape the majority rule, and in two ways that must be told apart.
First, a limit that no majority crosses: the meeting cannot, by whatever majority, impose on a co-owner a change to the purpose of their private parts, or to the way those parts may be enjoyed, as these result from the co-ownership rules (Article 18, first paragraph, of the Law of 16 May 1975). Obtaining unanimity does not make it possible either.
Second, decisions that the law subjects to the unanimity of co-owners: the disposal of common parts whose preservation is necessary to the purpose of the building (Article 18, second paragraph) and any change to the allocation of charges, subject to the adjustments the law provides for (Article 8, point 1, as amended by the Law of 22 April 1985).
Finally, the size of the budget does not, on its own, determine the applicable majority: what matters is the precise nature of the works or proposed change. And that nature has changed for a whole category. Since 1 October 2022, energy renovation works no longer fall under the double majority of Article 17 but under the Article 16 majority (points e), f) and g) of Article 16, added by the Law of 30 June 2022, whose Article 3 also replaced point c) of Article 17).
Works to install in-building high-speed network infrastructure — the physical infrastructure and the cabling between the network termination point and the first socket — escape the double majority: Article 17, point c), as replaced by the Law of 30 June 2022, expressly excludes them, and they do not appear in Article 16 either. The decision therefore falls under the Article 15 majority.
This exception is explained by the text that introduced it. The Law of 22 March 2017 requires the holder of the right to use the access point and the in-building physical infrastructure to grant reasonable access requests from an operator, on fair and non-discriminatory terms. Failing an agreement within two months of a formal request, the matter may be brought before the Institute, which settles it by a binding decision. An operator's access request therefore does not depend on a vote of the general meeting: the syndic who receives one does not have to put it to a majority — they have to answer it.
What difference do absence and abstention make?
An absence without representation removes voting rights from the calculation base under Article 15, but does not reduce the reference total under Article 16. An abstention, by contrast, does not drop out of the calculation: the majority is measured on the voting rights of the co-owners present or properly represented, abstentions included. On the outcome of the vote, an abstention therefore has the same effect as a vote against. It is presence, not the act of voting, that determines the base.
What should you check in the announced result?
The minutes should make it possible to understand which proposal was voted on, which majority rule was applied and how the outcome was calculated. If a figure seems surprising, ask for the calculation and compare it with the attendance sheet and proxy documents. A clear explanation is more useful than a discussion based only on how many hands were raised.
Reference texts and documents
Articles 15 to 19 of the Law of 16 May 1975. Article 19, first paragraph (reduction of the majority co-owner's voting rights) and Article 18 are in their 1975 wording. Article 19-1 (equal division of the votes), point d) of Article 16 and Article 8 result from the Law of 22 April 1985. Points e), f) and g) of Article 16 and point c) of Article 17 result from the Law of 30 June 2022, point c) of which refers in turn to the Law of 22 March 2017. Article 9 of the Grand-Ducal Regulation of 13 June 1975 for the calculation of majorities.
